When a serious disruption begins, the plan is rarely the first thing that fails. More often it is the decisions around the plan. Who has the authority to shut down a system that is still serving customers? When does an operational problem become a crisis that the executive team must own? Who speaks to customers, regulators, and the media, and what are they allowed to say before the facts are confirmed? How do technology, operations, legal, and communications teams keep a shared picture when each is seeing a different part of the event?
These questions are hard to answer in the abstract and harder still at two in the morning with incomplete information. Leaders who have rehearsed them together make faster, clearer, and more defensible decisions. Leaders who have not tend to discover their gaps in real time, in front of the people they serve.
This article looks at how to rehearse leadership decision-making and cross-team coordination so that, when it matters, the organization acts as one.
Why This Matters
Most disruptions are first handled operationally. A technology team responds to an alert, a facilities team manages a building issue, a supplier manager chases a late delivery. The moment that defines the outcome is often when the event crosses a threshold and needs leadership judgment: a decision about customer impact, public disclosure, regulatory notification, or a significant trade-off between speed and certainty.
External expectations increasingly put those decisions on a clock. For example, U.S. public companies subject to the SEC's 2023 cybersecurity disclosure rules must file a Form 8-K describing a material cybersecurity incident within four business days of determining that it is material, and that determination must be made without unreasonable delay. Other regimes, including DORA for EU financial entities, set their own incident classification and reporting expectations. Meeting these obligations depends on a leadership team that can assess impact, reach decisions, and coordinate disclosures quickly.
Guidance on crisis management reflects this. ISO 22361:2022 provides guidelines for building a strategic crisis management capability, with attention to crisis leadership, decision-making under uncertainty, communication, and validation through training and exercising. The underlying message is simple: crisis capability is a leadership competence that needs practice.
The Business Challenge
Leadership teams struggle with crisis decisions for reasons that have little to do with individual ability.
Unclear decision rights. Plans often say "the crisis management team will decide" without specifying who decides what. In practice, decisions bounce between functions, or are made by whoever is most senior in the room regardless of whether they hold the relevant authority.
Late escalation. Operational teams are understandably reluctant to escalate until they are sure an event is serious. By the time leaders are engaged, valuable hours have passed and options have narrowed.
Fragmented situational awareness. Technology sees system impact, operations sees customer impact, legal sees regulatory exposure, communications sees media interest. Without a deliberate effort to combine these, leaders make decisions on partial pictures.
Waiting for certainty. Experienced professionals are trained to confirm facts before acting. In a crisis, waiting for certainty can be the most costly decision of all.
Stress changes behavior. Under pressure, groups tend to anchor on the first explanation, defer to dominant voices, and narrow their attention. People who are thoughtful in ordinary meetings can make rushed or overly cautious choices when the stakes are high.
Rare practice. Many executive teams exercise once a year, if that, and the exercise is often a briefing rather than a genuine test of decision-making.
Key Concept: Exercise the Decisions, Not Just the Procedures
A leadership exercise should be designed around decisions, not around procedural steps. Technical teams need to practice procedures; executives need to practice judgment.
Map the decision points
Before designing a scenario, identify the decisions leaders would need to make in a serious event affecting your critical services. Common decision points include:
- Declaring a crisis and activating the crisis team.
- Accepting a deliberate service outage to contain a threat, such as isolating systems during a cyber incident.
- Deciding when and how to notify customers, regulators, law enforcement, insurers, and partners.
- Authorizing significant spending, such as emergency contractors or alternate facilities.
- Choosing between competing priorities, such as restoring one service ahead of another.
- Deciding whether to engage with or pay a threat actor, where relevant and lawful.
- Determining when to stand down and how to communicate recovery.
For each decision, clarify who holds the authority, who must be consulted, what information is needed, and what thresholds should trigger it.
Design scenarios that force those decisions
Build the scenario so that each priority decision point arrives under realistic conditions: limited information, time pressure, competing advice, and external demands. Introduce dilemmas where reasonable people could disagree, such as whether to notify customers before the scope of a data compromise is known. The goal is not to find the "right" answer but to see how the team reaches a decision and whether the process holds up.
Rehearse coordination across functions
Include the people who would really be in the room or on the call: technology, operations, legal, compliance, communications, human resources, and relevant business leaders. Where third parties would play a significant role, such as a critical cloud provider, an outsourced service operator, or an external incident response firm, consider including them or simulating their input realistically.
Anatomy of a sixty-minute decision drill
Short, focused drills are one of the most efficient ways to build executive decision-making capability. A typical structure looks like this.
Minutes 0 to 10: the opening picture. Participants receive a brief, deliberately incomplete situation report. For example, customer service is reporting a surge in complaints that online accounts show incorrect balances, technology has not yet identified a cause, and a social media post about the issue is gaining attention.
Minutes 10 to 25: the first decision. The facilitator asks the team to decide whether to declare a crisis, whether to take the online service offline while the cause is investigated, and what, if anything, to tell customers now. The team must name who owns each decision and what information they would want but do not have.
Minutes 25 to 40: the complication. A new inject arrives. Technology now suspects the incorrect balances stem from a faulty update at a third-party provider, but cannot confirm how many customers are affected. A regulator's supervision team has emailed asking for an update. The team must revisit its earlier decisions in light of new information.
Minutes 40 to 50: the trade-off. The provider offers a fix that would restore service within two hours but has not been fully tested. Leaders must weigh the risk of a second failure against the harm of a longer outage.
Minutes 50 to 60: the debrief. The group reviews what it decided, who decided, how long each decision took, and what information was missing. The observer shares the timeline of decisions recorded during the drill. Two or three actions are agreed before anyone leaves.
A drill like this takes an hour of executive time, yet it tests decision rights, escalation, external communication, third-party coordination, and risk trade-offs in a single session.
Signs a leadership team is ready
After several rounds of practice, ready teams share recognizable traits. They declare a crisis early and without hesitation. They state who owns each decision before debating it. They make provisional decisions, record the assumptions behind them, and revisit them on a set schedule. Their external messages are consistent because communications, legal, and operations work from the same situation report. And when the drill ends, they identify their own gaps before the facilitator does.
What Organizations Should Do
Clarify the crisis governance model
Document a simple structure: who leads, who decides which types of matters, how the operational and strategic levels interact, and how decisions are recorded. Keep it short enough that leaders can recall it under stress.
Define escalation thresholds
Agree on criteria that prompt escalation to leadership, framed in terms of impact on critical services, customers, safety, legal obligations, and reputation. Make it clear that early escalation is expected and that de-escalating a false alarm is a normal outcome, not an embarrassment.
Build a common operating picture
Agree in advance on how situational information will be gathered, summarized, and shared: a standard situation report format, a regular briefing rhythm, and a single place where the current picture lives. Exercise the process so that it becomes routine.
Prepare communication frameworks
Develop holding statements, stakeholder maps, and approval routes for the most likely scenarios. Rehearse how communications are coordinated with legal and regulatory notifications so that messages to customers, staff, regulators, and the public are consistent.
Exercise regularly and vary the format
Combine short, focused sessions, such as a sixty-minute decision drill on a single dilemma, with longer exercises that run through the full arc of an event. Vary scenarios across cyber, technology failure, supplier disruption, physical events, and reputational crises. Include at least some exercises with limited notice.
Capture how decisions were made
Assign an observer to record decisions, their timing, the information available, and the reasoning. Review these records afterward. They show whether decision rights worked, where information was missing, and how long key decisions took compared with what would be needed in a real event.
Leadership Considerations
Model the behavior you want. When the chief executive takes an exercise seriously, asks hard questions, and acknowledges personal gaps, the rest of the team follows.
Name the decision-maker. In every exercise, and in every real event, ask explicitly: who owns this decision? Ambiguity is a common cause of delay.
Decide with imperfect information. Practice making provisional decisions, stating the assumptions behind them, and setting a time to revisit them. This is a skill that improves with repetition.
Watch for group dynamics. Encourage dissent and assign someone to challenge the prevailing view during exercises. Teams that rehearse constructive challenge are less likely to fall into groupthink in a real event.
Prepare deputies. Crises do not wait for the right people to be available. Make sure deputies participate in exercises and are ready to act with the same authority.
Involve the board appropriately. Directors do not manage the response, but they need to know how and when they will be informed and what decisions might come to them. Consider periodic board-level sessions that walk through a scenario from the board's perspective.
How OpResONE Can Help
OpResONE builds leadership exercises that focus on decisions rather than scripts. We help leadership teams map decision points and authorities, define escalation thresholds, and build scenarios that create realistic pressure on judgment, coordination, and communication. Exercises can range from short decision drills to integrated simulations involving technology teams, business units, and critical suppliers.
After each exercise, we provide an evidence-based assessment of how decisions were made, where coordination broke down, and what to change, with actions that can be owned and tracked. Our crisis management and scenario testing advisory connects this work to your broader resilience program. For teams building in-house expertise, OpResONE also delivers PECB crisis management training courses as an authorized PECB partner.
Related Resources
- Scenario Testing & Exercises advisory
- Crisis Management advisory
- From Disruption to Opportunity
- Beyond the Tabletop
Rehearse Before It Counts
The time to discover how your leadership team makes decisions under pressure is before a real crisis. Schedule a Strategy Call to discuss a leadership exercise built around the decisions that matter most to your organization.
Sources
- U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, "SEC Adopts Rules on Cybersecurity Risk Management, Strategy, Governance, and Incident Disclosure by Public Companies" (July 26, 2023; Form 8-K Item 1.05)
- ISO, "ISO 22361:2022 Security and resilience — Crisis management — Guidelines"
- Regulation (EU) 2022/2554 (DORA), EUR-Lex

